OPINION: Pope Francis’s meaningful words must be followed by action

Thursday, 22 October 2020 14:22 GMT

Pope Francis wearing a face mask arrives for an inter-religious prayer service for peace along with other religious representatives in the Basilica of Santa Maria in Aracoeli, a church on top of Rome's Capitoline Hill, in Rome, Italy, October 20, 2020. REUTERS/Guglielmo Mangiapane

Image Caption and Rights Information

* Any views expressed in this opinion piece are those of the author and not of Thomson Reuters Foundation.

The pope's support for same-sex civil unions needs to be more than just backing LGBT+ people's basic human rights

Tuisina Ymania Brown and Luz Elena Aranda are co-secretaries general at ILGA World

When Pope Francis called for civil unions and spoke of the right of our LGBT+ communities to a family, the first reaction for many of us was joy. 

For Catholics, he is not only our spiritual father, but a hugely influential voice globally to hundreds of millions of people. His words of inclusion will resonate and hopefully drive inclusive change in countries, churches, communities and homes around the world.

After many years of being shut out in the darkness of exclusion, should we be surprised by these words that express support for us to access a most basic level of humanity?

Although unprecedented for a pope, the support expressed by His Holiness is a basic level of human right protection.

Yes, we have a right to a family.

Yes, whether or not we have come out, we hope that our families won’t turn away from us.

Yes, we have a right for our love to be legally recognised.

At least 28 UN member states have marriage equality, and 32 more recognise some form of civil partnership for same-sex couples. And while we celebrate the support from Pope Francis, it is also a reminder for us that what may be obvious for LGBT+ communities and allies may still not be for many across the world.

We are still conveniently scapegoated by conservatives and religious leaders for their own political gains, and the current pandemic has given us many examples of this – from campaigns in India falsely accusing trans people of spreading the virus, to multiple attempts to remove legal gender recognition.

Laws continue to target us. In 68 countries worldwide, for example, consensual same-sex relations are punished by law, and at least 13 have provisions that explicitly criminalise trans persons. From “conversion therapies” to medically unnecessary surgeries on intersex children, horrific practices are the harsh realities we’re subjected to. We are being told that we need to be “fixed”, despite our own knowledge that there is absolutely nothing wrong with us.

The acceptance and respect we call for is seldom given for granted by society at large, and this is why words such as those of Pope Francis will resonate with many in our communities. There is hope that we use them to potentially make a real lasting difference.

But whatever our reaction may have been while reading the words by Pope Francis, we know that they must be followed by actions.

Respect cannot be a pick-and-choose matter. It needs to be about all aspects of our lives, and not just our right to our families and our personal relationships, but also about everyone in our communities.

For far too long, the Church has been at best silent when our communities are attacked, or has actively contributed to those attacks itself.

The targeting of trans persons through odious and fallacious “gender ideology” arguments and the centuries-old limiting of the role of women in societies are two examples. Its long-standing silence on the damage caused by “conversion therapy”. Tolerating religious leaders who openly advocate for them. Refusing to stand up for the bodily integrity and protection of intersex persons. These actions continue to maim, hurt and kill LGBT+ people every day.

Many in our communities battle with trauma from the rejection we faced in religious spaces. But one day, faith must also be a part of the solution to open up conversations and bring change.

As this happens, it is vital that we pay special attention and listen to the members of LGBT+ communities with lived experiences of faith.

These meaningful dialogues are happening in many spaces, from local places of worship and families, to theological seminaries and regional gatherings, right up to the international level, including intra-denominational discussions and at the United Nations. These initiatives are often led by the courageous LGBT+ people of faith.

Meaningful words become a part of our dialogue, which lead to actions. Until that happens, the struggle for our communities will continue until all of us are truly free and equal.


FACTBOX - State of same-sex marriages globally as Pope Francis backs civil unions

EXPERT VIEWS - What does the Pope's support for gay civil unions mean for LGBT+ rights?

OPINION: Pope’s ‘yes’ to same-sex civil unions will lead to a more open and equal Catholic Church