What you need to know about appeal against Uganda anti-LGBTQ+ law

by Sadiya Ansari
Friday, 2 February 2024 14:07 GMT

Ugandan lawyer Gawaya Tegule delivers his submissions during the hearing of petitions and applications challenging the Anti-gay law at the constitutional court in Kampala, Uganda November 28, 2023. REUTERS/Abubaker Lubowa

Image Caption and Rights Information
Uganda's Constitutional Court set to rule on Anti-Homosexuality Act, but appeals likely
  • Uganda passed a strict anti-LGBTQ+ law in May
  • A legal challenge was heard in December
  • Petitioners say the law violates constitutional rights

By Sadiya Ansari

Feb 2 (Openly) – Rights groups expect Uganda's Constitutional Court to issue a verdict imminently on an appeal against the strict anti-LGBTQ+ law the country passed last year that imposed the death penalty for some same-sex acts.

Here's what you need to know.

What is the Anti-Homosexuality Act, and what has been its impact?

The Anti-Homosexuality Act was signed into law by President Yoweri Museveni in May 2023, and its draconian measures have prompted U.S. and World Bank sanctions.

While Uganda already criminalised gay sex, the new law is harsher, with the death penalty recommended for "serial offenders" and transmission of a terminal illness, such as HIV/AIDS, through gay sex.

The legislation also stipulates a 20-year sentence for "promoting" homosexuality, which includes activities such as publishing material deemed supportive, providing financial support or leasing property for "encouraging homosexuality".

It also introduced a "duty to report" suspected homosexual acts to the police.

At least five people have been charged under the law so far, including two for the capital offence of "aggravated homosexuality", which includes transmitting a terminal illness to someone through gay sex.

Rights groups have reported the new law has led to a surge in abuse against LGBTQ+ people, including torture, rape and evictions, primarily by private citizens.

Kampala-based Human Rights Awareness and Protection Forum compiled data from legal clinics three months after the law was enacted. It said people were "zealously" enforcing the law via "arrests of real or suspected LGBTQ persons continuing, as well as cases of violence and evictions from rented accommodation".

Who is challenging the law?

A group of lawmakers, legal experts and LGBTQ+ advocates filed a legal petition against the Anti-Homosexuality Act four days after it was passed in late May.

The respondents to the legal appeal include Uganda's attorney general and a Christian pastor, whom the court granted the status of co-defendant in December.

Why is the AHA being challenged?

The challenge falls into two broad categories: procedural issues and constitutional rights.

"The process (of passing the law) itself was unconstitutional, but also undermined the rules of parliament," said Kampala-based LGBTQ+ advocate Frank Mugisha, who is also one of the petitioners.

This includes issues such as lack of public consultation, and lack of accurate financial estimates related to the administration of the law, such as policing.

The last time Uganda passed a similar law, it was struck down in 2014 on procedural issues. Judge Steven Kavuma said the speaker of parliament had acted illegally by not accepting objections that pointed out there was no quorum for a vote.

But human rights advocates are hoping the law will be struck down in a way that demonstrates the independence of the judiciary and affirms the constitutional rights of LGBTQ+ people, said Larissa Kojoué, a researcher with Human Rights Watch.

"Civil society organisations will have a powerful tool for advocacy," Kojoué said.

Constitutional rights the petition cites as violated by the AHA include freedom of speech and association, and the right to privacy.

What happens next?

In a brief session in December, a panel of five judges received written submissions from both parties and the head of the panel, Richard Buteera, told the petitioners they would be notified when a ruling was ready.

Since the petition was expedited, Mugisha expects the ruling imminently, which will be delivered to the petitioners rather than heard in court.

"Local pressure from civil society and international pressure has contributed to ... show to Uganda (that this) is an urgent matter," said Mugisha, who is the executive director of umbrella rights group Sexual Minorities Uganda.

Once decided, the ruling can be appealed to the Supreme Court. If the law is struck down, Mugisha expects the government to appeal the decision, and if not, the petitioners will.

Kojoué hopes to see Uganda abide, not only by its own laws, but its international commitments.

The law, Kojoué said, "shouldn't exist in the country that has a constitution and pretends to be a democratic country."

This story is part of a series supported by HIVOS's Free To Be Me programme

Related stories:

How new anti-LGBTQ+ bills in Africa expand crackdown on rights

Ruling by Kenya's Supreme Court buoys LGBTQ+ community

What will the world do on LGBTQ+ rights in 2024?

Openly is an initiative of the Thomson Reuters Foundation dedicated to impartial coverage of LGBT+ issues from around the world.

Our Standards: The Thomson Reuters Trust Principles.

Update cookies preferences